Roizen’s Grading of Dyspnea

Shortness of breath, or dyspnea, is one of the most common and concerning symptoms encountered in a pre-operative assessment. It is a powerful indicator of compromised cardiopulmonary reserve. Roizen's Grading of Dyspnea is a simple, practical clinical scale designed to systematically quantify the severity of this symptom. Developed by Dr. Michael Roizen, it provides anesthesiologists and other clinicians with a standardized language to describe a patient's functional limitation from breathlessness, which is crucial for perioperative risk stratification.

While similar in concept to the NYHA classification, Roizen's scale focuses specifically on the symptom of dyspnea rather than the broader syndrome of heart failure, making it a valuable tool for assessing patients with respiratory, cardiac, or mixed etiologies for their breathlessness.

---

The Five Grades of Dyspnea

The scale consists of five grades, from 0 (no symptoms) to 4 (dyspnea at rest). The assessment is based on the patient's report of their symptoms during specific levels of physical exertion.

---

Grade 0: No Dyspnea

• Definition: The patient experiences no shortness of breath, even with strenuous physical activity.
• Explanation: This indicates excellent or preserved cardiopulmonary reserve. The patient's heart and lungs are able to meet the body's oxygen demands during peak exertion without causing the sensation of breathlessness.
• Example: A 40-year-old who can run a 5k or carry heavy groceries up multiple flights of stairs without feeling winded.

Grade 1: Dyspnea on Strenuous Exertion

• Definition: The patient is comfortable with normal, everyday activities but becomes short of breath only during very strenuous exercise.
• Explanation: This represents a very mild limitation. The patient's reserve is mostly intact, but it can be overwhelmed by extreme physical demands that exceed those of daily living.
• Example: A 55-year-old who can walk, climb a flight of stairs, and do housework without issue, but becomes breathless when sprinting to catch a bus or shoveling heavy snow.

Grade 2: Dyspnea on Moderate Exertion

• Definition: The patient becomes short of breath with moderate levels of activity, such as walking up a hill or climbing more than one flight of stairs.
• Explanation: This is a mild to moderate limitation. The patient's functional capacity is reduced, and activities that are considered normal for a healthy individual now cause symptoms.
• Example: A 65-year-old with well-controlled heart failure who feels fine walking on level ground but has to stop and catch their breath after climbing two flights of stairs.

Grade 3: Dyspnea on Mild Exertion

• Definition: The patient experiences shortness of breath with minimal exertion, such as walking on level ground.
• Explanation: This indicates a severe functional limitation. The patient's cardiopulmonary reserve is so low that even the basic activities of daily living are enough to cause significant dyspnea.
• Example: A 75-year-old with severe COPD who becomes breathless after walking just half a block or from the bedroom to the kitchen.

Grade 4: Dyspnea at Rest

• Definition: The patient is short of breath even while at complete rest. Any physical activity, no matter how small, worsens the symptom.
• Explanation: This is a critical state indicating profound cardiopulmonary failure. The body's oxygen demands cannot be met even without any physical activity. This is a sign of end-stage disease.
• Example: A patient in acute decompensated heart failure who is sitting upright in a chair (orthopnea) and is still struggling to breathe, unable to speak in full sentences.

---

Clinical Application in Anesthesia

Roizen's Grading of Dyspnea is an essential component of the pre-operative evaluation for several reasons:

• Predictor of Postoperative Complications: A higher grade (≥3) is strongly associated with an increased risk of postoperative respiratory failure, pneumonia, atelectasis, and the need for prolonged mechanical ventilation.
• Assessment of Cardiopulmonary Reserve: It provides a quick, functional assessment of how well a patient's heart and lungs can cope with stress. Surgery and anesthesia are significant physiological stressors.
• Guiding Further Investigation: A patient with Grade 2 or higher dyspnea should prompt a more detailed workup to determine the underlying cause (e.g., echocardiogram, pulmonary function tests, cardiology/pulmonology consult).
• Anesthetic and Pain Management Planning: Knowing a patient has limited reserve influences anesthetic choices. For example, a clinician might favor a regional anesthetic over a general one, or be very cautious with opioid dosing postoperatively to avoid respiratory depression in a patient with Grade 3 dyspnea.
• Informed Consent: It provides a tangible metric to discuss with the patient when explaining their increased risk and the potential need for postoperative intensive care.

Limitations

• Subjectivity: The scale relies entirely on the patient's perception, which can be influenced by their pain tolerance, anxiety level, or stoicism.
• Lack of Etiology: The grade describes the severity of the symptom but does not identify the cause (e.g., heart failure vs. COPD vs. anemia). Further investigation is always required.
• Overlap with Other Scales: It is very similar to the MRC (Medical Research Council) dyspnea scale and components of the NYHA classification. The choice of which to use often comes down to institutional preference or the specific context of the assessment.

 

Roizen's Grading of Dyspnea Summary